Netflix’s Midnight Mass has captivated audiences with its haunting narrative, philosophical depth, and powerhouse performances. Created by horror maestro Mike Flanagan, the seven-episode miniseries explores faith, death, and redemption in a remote island town—brought to life by a brilliant ensemble cast.
⭐ Full Cast of Midnight Mass (2021): Who’s Who on Crockett Island?
🔹 Zach Gilford as Riley Flynn
Riley is a troubled former tech entrepreneur returning to Crockett Island after serving time for a tragic accident. Zach Gilford (Friday Night Lights) delivers a nuanced performance, portraying Riley’s struggle with guilt and belief in a world that feels devoid of hope.
🔹 Kate Siegel as Erin Greene
Kate Siegel (The Haunting of Hill House, Hush) plays Erin, a schoolteacher and Riley’s childhood love. Pregnant and seeking peace, Erin's arc is emotional and profound—Siegel anchors her with quiet strength and grace.
🔹 Hamish Linklater as Father Paul Hill
If you’re searching “who plays Father Paul in Midnight Mass,” it’s none other than Hamish Linklater. His mesmerizing portrayal of the mysterious priest is one of the most lauded performances in recent horror TV. Father Paul’s arrival sets off a chain of miracles—and eerie events—that shake the island to its core.
🔹 Samantha Sloyan as Bev Keane
Sloyan plays the fanatically devout Bev Keane, a character audiences love to hate. Her chilling embodiment of religious extremism adds psychological depth to the show’s theological themes.
🔹 Rahul Kohli as Sheriff Hassan
Rahul Kohli (The Haunting of Bly Manor) plays Sheriff Hassan, a Muslim father and outsider in the tight-knit Catholic community. His calm, principled demeanor and protective nature—especially toward his son, Ali—add a vital counterbalance to the island’s mounting tension.
🔹 Annabeth Gish as Dr. Sarah Gunning
As the island’s doctor, Sarah Gunning (played by Gish) stands firm in science, even as unexplainable events unfold. Her quiet heroism and tragic backstory add emotional weight to the series' climax.
🔹 Henry Thomas as Ed Flynn
A frequent Flanagan collaborator, Henry Thomas (E.T., Doctor Sleep) plays Riley’s devout father. His journey from denial to heartbreak is quietly devastating.
🎭 Supporting Midnight Mass Cast Members
-
Alex Essoe as Mildred Gunning – Dr. Sarah’s mother, who undergoes a mysterious transformation.
-
Annarah Cymone as Leeza Scarborough – A paralyzed girl who experiences a “miracle” under Father Paul.
-
Igby Rigney as Warren Flynn – Riley’s younger brother, representing the island’s younger generation.
-
Matt Biedel as Sturge – A key church volunteer and Father Paul loyalist.
🏆 Critical Reception & Awards
Midnight Mass was praised for its script, performances, and thought-provoking dialogue. On Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds an 87% critic score. Hamish Linklater received standout praise and awards recognition, including a Critics Choice Super Award for Best Actor in a Horror Series.
🎖️ Did you know? Mike Flanagan has called Midnight Mass his most personal project yet—drawing inspiration from his own experiences with addiction and religious doubt.
📺 Where to Watch Midnight Mass
All 7 episodes of Midnight Mass are available to stream exclusively on Netflix. Each episode is titled after a book of the Bible, reinforcing the show’s deep religious symbolism and thematic undertones.
👉 Watch Midnight Mass on Netflix
🔍 Final Thoughts: Why the Midnight Mass Cast Made This a Must-Watch
The cast of Midnight Mass delivers one of the most emotionally resonant and chilling performances in modern horror television. Whether you're here to find out “who plays Father Paul in Midnight Mass” or to explore the ensemble behind this masterpiece, the performances will stay with you long after the final credits roll.