Since bursting onto the WWE scene , Pat McAfee has defied expectations. Known originally for his NFL punting skills and later as a charismatic sports analyst and podcast host, McAfee’s transition to wrestling was met with both skepticism and excitement. Yet, the former Indianapolis Colts star quickly proved he wasn't just another celebrity cameo. He brought real energy, agility, and storytelling to the squared circle. In this post, we explore who Pat McAfee has wrestled since making his wrestling debut—and why each match was a significant moment in his career. 🧨 Pat McAfee vs. Adam Cole – A Feud Fueled by Real Tension 🥊 The rivalry between Pat McAfee and Adam Cole in 2020 marked McAfee’s in-ring debut and set the tone for how seriously he was taking his wrestling career. Their feud began on McAfee’s podcast, where tensions seemed to boil over—blurring the lines between reality and scripted drama. Their first major match came at NXT TakeOver: XXX . Despite being a wrestlin...